Estimated Reading Time: 3
There was a commotion in the Senate on Tuesday as Senators Eyinnaya Abaribe (PDP-Abia) Abaribe and Ajibola Basiru (APC-Osun) protested a bill proposed by Senator Yahaya Abdullahi (APC-Kebbi).
The Bill entitled: “A Bill for an Act to regulate the slaughter of donkeys and establish the breeding and ranching of donkeys through the export certification value chain to mitigate the extinction of donkeys, 2021” was seeking to regulate donkey business in the country.
The Donkey Business Bill however scaled second reading following the presentation of the lead debate on the bill by its sponsor at plenary.
Leading the debate on the general principles of the Bill, Senator Abdullahi recalled the Bill was read for the first time on Wednesday, September 30, 2020.
According to him, the Bill is seeking to enable the country to derive the utmost benefit from the donkey hides export market.
“This is by regulation instead of an outright ban of the business that will compel the value chain players to go underground and ultimately increase the smuggling of the product, due to the huge demand for the product in far eastern countries like China.”
Other objectives of the Bill, he said, included: @providing opportunities for responsible donkey breeding for those who wished to go into the business, to be able to follow laid down procedures for such value chain operations.”
Abdullahi noted that the Bill would further complement the import and export of raw animal hides and skins especially that of the donkey, currently on the Customs Prohibition List.
Midway into the debate, Senator Abaribe (PDP-Abia) raised a Constitutional Point of Order, saying that the debate on the Bill did not fall under the jurisdiction of the Senate to legislate on.
“Ordinarily, I will expect that as parliament, we should look at the Constitution before certain things are put up here,” Abaribe said.
Senator Sabi Abdullahi (APC-Niger) while reacting to Abaribe’s position, said: “I’m a Veterinarian by training and I will recall when, in the Federal Ministry of Agriculture, the issue of donkey going into extinction in Nigeria was discussed and approved in 2004 at the National Council on Agriculture and Rural Development in Sokoto.
“This Bill is something this country needs and we should support it,” Abdullahi said.
Also speaking against the Bill, Senator Ajibola Basiru (APC-Osun) said: “The fact that a subject matter is desirable, its necessity does not automatically confer on the federal legislative arm, the legislative competence to do so.
“Section 1 (3) of our Constitution is very clear as to superiority provision that any Act or Law contrary to the provision of the Constitution is to the extent of that inconsistency, null and void.
”The argument of whether cattle or donkey is going into extinction is beyond the point,” Bashiru said.
In his remarks, President of the Senate, Ahmad Lawan stated: “The Bill is concerning the donkey, not the donkey for commercial purposes, but the extinction of the donkey.
“I believe that we could legislate on this and any other livestock if we feel that will not disproportionately destroy our ecosystem.
“Secondly, even if we are looking at the economic value of the donkey not in terms of selling it, but in terms of keeping the environment balanced, I believe we have the jurisdiction to legislate on that.
“And based on our Standing Order 25 which gives me the chance, donated by you to interpret the rules, I rule that we can go ahead and take this bill.”
Lawan, thereafter, referred the Bill to the Committee on Agriculture and Rural Development to report back in two weeks.